Home » Television » Rose Tyler vs Martha Jones
Rose Tyler VS Martha Jones Doctor Who

Rose Tyler vs Martha Jones

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
  • iamhumanboy

    I'm not sure when exactly it happened, but Rose turned into a badass. She wins.

    • iamhumanboyenemy

      youre a bit old to look at 2 women on doctor who arent you!

    • The Doctor

      “Martha did everything by herself because the Doctor didn’t care about her during her run. She’s smart, she’s a doctor, she traveled the world even though the Master and his bitches were hunting her down, she left the Doctor with her head held high, she was an asset to UNIT, she was willing to sacrifice her planet for the good of the universe, she held her own against the Sontarans…

      Rose was assisted at all times by the Doctor because he (for some reason) loved her. She’s only clever when RTD wanted to make her look good, excluding those times she was dumb and useless. She worked in a shop instead of having a real career, which would be okay with me if she didn’t whine about it without really having any ambition or trying to make her life better at all. The only thing that she’s ever done to help the Doctor is that she went back for him in the series 1 finale, but even then he had to die to save her. She was a bitch to Mickey, Reinette, Sarah Jane, and basically everyone else she came across. She was willing to sacrifice the whole universe just so she could see the Doctor again (even though he’d die if she DID destroy the universe), but that’s not as bad as not having any aspirations in life. Then she runs off with a living, breathing Doctor sex doll, breaking the real Doctor’s heart and forgetting any ambition she’d ever had. Three words- WORST. COMPANION. EVER.

      Martha all the way. What an underrated companion.”

      -Hello

  • torchwood fighter

    rose

    • The Doctor

      This is why i disagree:

      “Martha did everything by herself because the Doctor didn’t care about her during her run. She’s smart, she’s a doctor, she traveled the world even though the Master and his bitches were hunting her down, she left the Doctor with her head held high, she was an asset to UNIT, she was willing to sacrifice her planet for the good of the universe, she held her own against the Sontarans…

      Rose was assisted at all times by the Doctor because he (for some reason) loved her. She’s only clever when RTD wanted to make her look good, excluding those times she was dumb and useless. She worked in a shop instead of having a real career, which would be okay with me if she didn’t whine about it without really having any ambition or trying to make her life better at all. The only thing that she’s ever done to help the Doctor is that she went back for him in the series 1 finale, but even then he had to die to save her. She was a bitch to Mickey, Reinette, Sarah Jane, and basically everyone else she came across. She was willing to sacrifice the whole universe just so she could see the Doctor again (even though he’d die if she DID destroy the universe), but that’s not as bad as not having any aspirations in life. Then she runs off with a living, breathing Doctor sex doll, breaking the real Doctor’s heart and forgetting any ambition she’d ever had. Three words- WORST. COMPANION. EVER.

      Martha all the way. What an underrated companion.”

      -Hello

  • Abastor

    Hi, what about a brawl between DALEKS and CYBERMEN?!
    ;-)

    • random

      there was a battle against the dales and cybermen. the cybermen turned on to rose and 10th doctor’s team and i think the dales exterminated them all anyway. it was part 1 of Rose’s last episode with the doctor :-((((((

  • thain

    I love rose

    • The Doctor

      so? doesn’t mean she wins.

  • HRC

    Badass Badwolf.

    • thousand voices

      I agree completely. Martha Jones may be completely amazing but you know……Rose Tyer wins. :)

  • Ray-za

    Rose Tyler, total curbstomp.

    • The Doctor

      “Martha did everything by herself because the Doctor didn’t care about her during her run. She’s smart, she’s a doctor, she traveled the world even though the Master and his bitches were hunting her down, she left the Doctor with her head held high, she was an asset to UNIT, she was willing to sacrifice her planet for the good of the universe, she held her own against the Sontarans…

      Rose was assisted at all times by the Doctor because he (for some reason) loved her. She’s only clever when RTD wanted to make her look good, excluding those times she was dumb and useless. She worked in a shop instead of having a real career, which would be okay with me if she didn’t whine about it without really having any ambition or trying to make her life better at all. The only thing that she’s ever done to help the Doctor is that she went back for him in the series 1 finale, but even then he had to die to save her. She was a bitch to Mickey, Reinette, Sarah Jane, and basically everyone else she came across. She was willing to sacrifice the whole universe just so she could see the Doctor again (even though he’d die if she DID destroy the universe), but that’s not as bad as not having any aspirations in life. Then she runs off with a living, breathing Doctor sex doll, breaking the real Doctor’s heart and forgetting any ambition she’d ever had. Three words- WORST. COMPANION. EVER.

      Martha all the way. What an underrated companion.”

      -Hello

  • Nadine_brazilian

    I hate Martha.She haven’t chances to win!I like Rose.She is a PERFECT compagnher

    • The Doctor

      Fuck You. Now, like so:

      “Martha did everything by herself because the Doctor didn’t care about her during her run. She’s smart, she’s a doctor, she traveled the world even though the Master and his bitches were hunting her down, she left the Doctor with her head held high, she was an asset to UNIT, she was willing to sacrifice her planet for the good of the universe, she held her own against the Sontarans…

      Rose was assisted at all times by the Doctor because he (for some reason) loved her. She’s only clever when RTD wanted to make her look good, excluding those times she was dumb and useless. She worked in a shop instead of having a real career, which would be okay with me if she didn’t whine about it without really having any ambition or trying to make her life better at all. The only thing that she’s ever done to help the Doctor is that she went back for him in the series 1 finale, but even then he had to die to save her. She was a bitch to Mickey, Reinette, Sarah Jane, and basically everyone else she came across. She was willing to sacrifice the whole universe just so she could see the Doctor again (even though he’d die if she DID destroy the universe), but that’s not as bad as not having any aspirations in life. Then she runs off with a living, breathing Doctor sex doll, breaking the real Doctor’s heart and forgetting any ambition she’d ever had. Three words- WORST. COMPANION. EVER.

      Martha all the way. What an underrated companion.”

      -Hello

  • BRAIN.EXE

    Referencing Bad Wolf, ROSE!!!

    • The Doctor

      no.

  • ProudNerd

    Rose absorbed the TARDIS’s energy/soul and dissintergrated 2000+ daleks without trying, Tyler FTW.

    BTW for those who don’t know TARDIS means Time And Relative Dimensions In Space. The time machine.

    • The Doctor

      Awesome quote to explain my argument: “Martha did everything by herself because the Doctor didn’t care about her during her run. She’s smart, she’s a doctor, she traveled the world even though the Master and his bitches were hunting her down, she left the Doctor with her head held high, she was an asset to UNIT, she was willing to sacrifice her planet for the good of the universe, she held her own against the Sontarans…

      Rose was assisted at all times by the Doctor because he (for some reason) loved her. She’s only clever when RTD wanted to make her look good, excluding those times she was dumb and useless. She worked in a shop instead of having a real career, which would be okay with me if she didn’t whine about it without really having any ambition or trying to make her life better at all. The only thing that she’s ever done to help the Doctor is that she went back for him in the series 1 finale, but even then he had to die to save her. She was a bitch to Mickey, Reinette, Sarah Jane, and basically everyone else she came across. She was willing to sacrifice the whole universe just so she could see the Doctor again (even though he’d die if she DID destroy the universe), but that’s not as bad as not having any aspirations in life. Then she runs off with a living, breathing Doctor sex doll, breaking the real Doctor’s heart and forgetting any ambition she’d ever had. Three words- WORST. COMPANION. EVER.

      Martha all the way. What an underrated companion.”

      -Hello

  • Sophie

    Gosh I just no all the Rose fans are going to hate me for this but . . . Martha. She’s smarter, she’s probably got some combat training from UNIT – even though she was just a doctor, but then in the season finale we saw her and Mickey fighting a Sontaron, so she can probably hold her own in a fight – plus, Martha traveled around the world, evading the Master’s spies and army, pretending to be gathering items to kill the Master but in actuality was acting as the Doctor’s disciple and telling everyone about him. I love Rose, I do, and she did turn into quite the badass, but I just like Martha a tad more.

  • Hello

    Martha did everything by herself because the Doctor didn’t care about her during her run. She’s smart, she’s a doctor, she traveled the world even though the Master and his bitches were hunting her down, she left the Doctor with her head held high, she was an asset to UNIT, she was willing to sacrifice her planet for the good of the universe, she held her own against the Sontarans…

    Rose was assisted at all times by the Doctor because he (for some reason) loved her. She’s only clever when RTD wanted to make her look good, excluding those times she was dumb and useless. She worked in a shop instead of having a real career, which would be okay with me if she didn’t whine about it without really having any ambition or trying to make her life better at all. The only thing that she’s ever done to help the Doctor is that she went back for him in the series 1 finale, but even then he had to die to save her. She was a bitch to Mickey, Reinette, Sarah Jane, and basically everyone else she came across. She was willing to sacrifice the whole universe just so she could see the Doctor again (even though he’d die if she DID destroy the universe), but that’s not as bad as not having any aspirations in life. Then she runs off with a living, breathing Doctor sex doll, breaking the real Doctor’s heart and forgetting any ambition she’d ever had. Three words- WORST. COMPANION. EVER.

    Martha all the way. What an underrated companion.

    • thereyouare

      Worst companion ever? I don’t think so. You forget that Rose spent some time at Torchwood, sent the Devil through a black hole, and wiped out an entire fleet of Daleks, and saved the Doctor from the Autons on their very first adventure. Also, if it wasn’t for Rose, then Martha would have never existed. Rose’s failure would have meant the end of the Doctor Who revival. Also, she wasn’t a bitch to Reinette, Sarah Jane was just as snotty, if not more snotty to Rose, (they did make up though). and obviously you weren’t really watching Rose because she showed great compassion towards everyone. You are completely wrong and Rose would beat Martha in a fight.

      • The Doctor

        hahahahhaha go fuck yourself.

    • gigglypuffs

      Finally someone said it! haha I feel like everyone thinks Rose Tyler poops gold, when she doesn’t. haha You, my friend, just made my week.

    • The Doctor

      Best. Argument. EVAR.

    • Nicola

      Rose was 19! What 19 year old has a real career unless it is in entertainment???? She is a teenager with a full time job, partially supporting her mother, who initially turns DOWN the Doctor on traveling because she feels RESPONSIBLE for people…like Mickey and Jackie. She is also a street smart, tough woman.

  • Hello

    Martha did everything by herself because the Doctor didn’t care about her during her run. She’s smart, she’s a doctor, she traveled the world even though the Master and his bitches were hunting her down, she left the Doctor with her head held high, she was an asset to UNIT, she was willing to sacrifice her planet for the good of the universe, she held her own against the Sontarans…

    Rose was assisted at all times by the Doctor because he (for some reason) loved her. She’s only clever when RTD wanted to make her look good, excluding those times she was dumb and useless. She worked in a shop instead of having a real career, which would be okay with me if she didn’t whine about it without really having any ambition or trying to make her life better at all. The only thing that she’s ever done to help the Doctor is that she went back for him in the series 1 finale, but even then he had to die to save her. She was a bitch to Mickey, Reinette, Sarah Jane, and basically everyone else she came across. She was willing to sacrifice the whole universe just so she could see the Doctor again (even though he’d die if she DID destroy the universe), but that’s not as bad as not having any aspirations in life. Then she runs off with a living, breathing Doctor sex doll, breaking the real Doctor’s heart and forgetting any ambition she’d ever had. Three words- WORST. COMPANION. EVER.

    Martha all the way. What an underrated companion.

  • Dan

    Chavs fight dirty. Rose wins.

    • The Doctor

      “Martha did everything by herself because the Doctor didn’t care about her during her run. She’s smart, she’s a doctor, she traveled the world even though the Master and his bitches were hunting her down, she left the Doctor with her head held high, she was an asset to UNIT, she was willing to sacrifice her planet for the good of the universe, she held her own against the Sontarans…

      Rose was assisted at all times by the Doctor because he (for some reason) loved her. She’s only clever when RTD wanted to make her look good, excluding those times she was dumb and useless. She worked in a shop instead of having a real career, which would be okay with me if she didn’t whine about it without really having any ambition or trying to make her life better at all. The only thing that she’s ever done to help the Doctor is that she went back for him in the series 1 finale, but even then he had to die to save her. She was a bitch to Mickey, Reinette, Sarah Jane, and basically everyone else she came across. She was willing to sacrifice the whole universe just so she could see the Doctor again (even though he’d die if she DID destroy the universe), but that’s not as bad as not having any aspirations in life. Then she runs off with a living, breathing Doctor sex doll, breaking the real Doctor’s heart and forgetting any ambition she’d ever had. Three words- WORST. COMPANION. EVER.

      Martha all the way. What an underrated companion.”

      -Hello

      d

  • http://www.facebook.com/maggie.harris.967 Maggie Harris

    As a writer, I prefer Rose because I enjoyed watching her character develop. She seemed to grow into a braver, more responsible person as the series wore on. Martha, while an awesome character, basically started as the “end product”. It feels like the authors just didn’t want us to go through the same sort of character development “all over again”, and as a result she just didn’t have the same amount of depth.

  • rockyslayer

    Martha would ask rose to do a sexy pose and then would slice her neck open

  • RoseTaylorFuckMartha

    Martha is a bitch,
    Rose is better !

    • The Doctor

      NO.

      “Martha did everything by herself because the Doctor didn’t care about her during her run. She’s smart, she’s a doctor, she traveled the world even though the Master and his bitches were hunting her down, she left the Doctor with her head held high, she was an asset to UNIT, she was willing to sacrifice her planet for the good of the universe, she held her own against the Sontarans…

      Rose was assisted at all times by the Doctor because he (for some reason) loved her. She’s only clever when RTD wanted to make her look good, excluding those times she was dumb and useless. She worked in a shop instead of having a real career, which would be okay with me if she didn’t whine about it without really having any ambition or trying to make her life better at all. The only thing that she’s ever done to help the Doctor is that she went back for him in the series 1 finale, but even then he had to die to save her. She was a bitch to Mickey, Reinette, Sarah Jane, and basically everyone else she came across. She was willing to sacrifice the whole universe just so she could see the Doctor again (even though he’d die if she DID destroy the universe), but that’s not as bad as not having any aspirations in life. Then she runs off with a living, breathing Doctor sex doll, breaking the real Doctor’s heart and forgetting any ambition she’d ever had. Three words- WORST. COMPANION. EVER.

      Martha all the way. What an underrated companion.”

      -Hello

  • random

    well obviously rose. plus she is awesome

    • The Doctor

      “Martha did everything by herself because the Doctor didn’t care about her during her run. She’s smart, she’s a doctor, she traveled the world even though the Master and his bitches were hunting her down, she left the Doctor with her head held high, she was an asset to UNIT, she was willing to sacrifice her planet for the good of the universe, she held her own against the Sontarans…

      Rose was assisted at all times by the Doctor because he (for some reason) loved her. She’s only clever when RTD wanted to make her look good, excluding those times she was dumb and useless. She worked in a shop instead of having a real career, which would be okay with me if she didn’t whine about it without really having any ambition or trying to make her life better at all. The only thing that she’s ever done to help the Doctor is that she went back for him in the series 1 finale, but even then he had to die to save her. She was a bitch to Mickey, Reinette, Sarah Jane, and basically everyone else she came across. She was willing to sacrifice the whole universe just so she could see the Doctor again (even though he’d die if she DID destroy the universe), but that’s not as bad as not having any aspirations in life. Then she runs off with a living, breathing Doctor sex doll, breaking the real Doctor’s heart and forgetting any ambition she’d ever had. Three words- WORST. COMPANION. EVER.

      Martha all the way. What an underrated companion.”

      -Hello

      Listen to Hello.

  • Bluey3214

    Martha would win for sure I mean she must have UNIT training so she can probably throw a hard punch. She also went a whole year without the doctor accompanying her. She saved the world (technically universe) but the doctor still didn’t even bother to appreciate her and that’s why she left. She is a badass.