Who Would Win in a Brawl?!

Homer would win hands down. Have you seen him choke Bart?

Peter would put up a good fight (chicken style) but I think he’d lose.

peter is strong and heavy

I can’t deside because both of them would but up a good fight.

peter griffin is way funnier than homer and hes awesome

i vote for peter because peter is funny.

i vote for homer
because he is
funny

because i have been watching famliy guy for years and i have the video game too.

um peter griffin would totally pone homer simpson using awesomeness alone.

Homer would win because Peter would keep distracting himself with random cutaways while Homer remained on the main plot line of kicking Peter’s ass.

Couldn’t have said it better myself.

peter is strong and heavy

Peter is REALLY fat and heavy and it looks like he could kill Homer if he wanted to. Peter would definitely win.

Homer is a solid chubby whereas Peter is just chubby.

peter would have some crazy shananigance happen mid fight and homer would end up losing

Peter Griffin would would because… Hes funnier and could kill homer by laying on him!

I'm sure they would both put up a really good fight but in the end Homer would win. Homer has decades of experience strangling Bart and has fought different people over the years. Homer also has a thick skull protecting him from being knocked out and has severe anger issues. Peter only seems to have experience fighting that Giant Chicken and had his ass kicked when Joe got his legs back and took up Karate. When Homer fights, he really fights. Peter would get distracted by a sunflower seed on the ground while Homer smashes his Peter's face.

Oh, and on numerous occassions, Homer has neglected and expressed hatred towards his father and has dreams of killing him. Peter doesn't have the level of anger Homer has.

i have to reject it… the chicken fight shows, how angry peter can, if he want. And don't forget the yogi bear incident too! I vote for Peter. He is awesome. ps: i like Homer too, but he is too stupid to parry Peters blows

peter would win easily!! Homer sucks and family guy is way funnier and better!

seriously? homer has taken more beatings to the head than wile-e-cyote (beaten by 3 mugs, saws falling on him, a mike tyson spoof on steroids). MargeisHot is right, too, he only fights that stupid chicken and lost miserably to joe. besides some people say peter is way funnier or their would be some cutaway scene distracting them. if it was a full-on contact fight, homer would triumph. although i will admit the simpsons has gotten a lot stupider these past couple years.

Sadly, Peter would win. Homer has become a major punching bag nowadays. He loses to Jimbo’s Dolph, and Kearney’s dads, he loses to Groundskeeper Wille, he loses to Buck Mitchell, nearly, killed by Dredrick Tatum, he loses to Tom (Bart’s big brother-guardian), he also loses to random bodyguards, security guards, and cops (realistic no-nonsense cops outside of Chief Wiggum, Lou, and Eddie). Even in Hulk Mode, he is dog-piled by the cops. Peter on the other hand, can beat the crap out of almost anyone and has more balls than Homer. I wish Homer had the same spunk as Peter. Even outside of brawls, Homer can’t even defend himself against the Springfieldians, more or less his own family, especially his wife, Marge (who blames him for nearly everything). Peter actually put Lois in her place on two occasions and has no problem attacking her.

homer will and shall win.  he has a high tolerance for pain.