Hobbit vs. Wizard

Movies

Loading …

Buy The Lord of the Rings Boxset at Amazon | Buy Harry Potter Years 1-5 at Amazon

humanboy

Frodo would probably get his ass kicked here. He might have taken down an Orc or two, but standing up against a wizard isn’t likely.

ben

although i think lord of the rings far surpasses harry pottter as a story, the main character in rowlings book beats the living tar out of frodo baggins

jtdc

Name one thing Frodo ever fought and one. Now that we've finished this, Harry fought the most feared evil being to the death and won before he was shaving daily.

Frodo is a pussy.

http://twitter.com/chocoholicarmen Carmen Bishop

How about the Dark Lord, (via destrying the ring on a several-month journey through the lands with nothing but a sword and a few loyal friends? No wand to help him!)
Harry WOULD own Frodo in this, but I still love Frodo better just because he is so… NICE, harry can be a bit obnoxious and arrogant sometimes.
Don't kill me! I still LOVE harry potter more than LOTR, just I like Frodo better than harry. I like Ron better than Sam though… The weasley twins and Merry&Pippin = I can't chose between them! <3333333
Rant over!

Stevejones

fcuk off frodo can go invis and has a shinjy sword while harry is gahy

CantSpellMyName

Bla bla bla bla bla…
Bonnia

Harry has an Invisibility Cloak and the Sword of Gryffindor and a wand. :/

Ana_dgc

Bitch, Frodo have all the power of Gandalf. Beat that.

Leonel

Exactly, Frodo can use the One Ring and Stabbed Harry
CantSpellMyName

Harry in every way possible, Frodo didn’t even have a strong enough will to throw the Ring into the mountain of Doom, Middle-Earth would have been fucked without Gollum. Harry can be a crybaby but he’s Chuck Norris compared to Frodo, and he’s far more skilled. Frodo would probably die from Expelliarmus, lol.

Leonel

That’s ridiculous, of course he can kill Harry by stabbing him, just place the One Ring in his finger and stab Harry in the back.

Simple. LOL

CantSpellMyName

Any protection charm would prevent Frodo from doing so, but yeah, if he manages to take Harry by surprise he could kill him that way. Would be a really cheap victory though.

Leonel

But is that what i’am talking about, Frodo probably will take Mister Potter in a surprise attack stabbing him.

Andy V

by that same thinking harry could put on his invisibility cloak and kill frodo just as easy.

lotrmuhfukka

you wouldnt have enough will to through it in either dumbass. frodo turns invisible and kicks harrys dumb expelliarmus ass.

CantSpellMyName

Ok, first of all I don’t take anyone calling me a dumbass, is that clear you smug fuck?? And Harry has an invisibility device too that he can use just as easily, did you miss that part? Expelliarmus would take care of Sting in a second so don’t say shit about it.

CantSpellMyName

And unlike Frodo, Harry also has a spell that can detect Frodo even with his Ring on. It is called homenum revelio, all Harry has to do is being smart enough to use it. Otherwise he could just put up a Protego charm beforehand and Frodo could jump around him invisible all day trying to stab him while Harry would just laugh at him.

http://profile.yahoo.com/IYJ5EV3JRFJH5OVMJOLB2LY2U4 Sarah Torgerson

Expelliarmus works with WANDS. Frodo obviously did not have the real advantage, but suppose that putting on the ring didn’t kill him, there is no spell to stop Frodo from going up and stabbing Harry in the back.

CantSpellMyName

Wrong. Expelliarmus will disarm a person of whatever he/she is holding, be it a wand, gun, or a knife, it is NOT limited to wands. Quote from Harry Potter wiki: “The Disarming Charm is a defensive charm that disarms an opponent, causing whatever is in the person’s hand at the time, usually a wand, to fly out of his or her hand.” Sorry, but you’re wrong, expelliarmus would work just fine against Sting or a knife.

Star Killer

Man, Harry and Frodo are cool
Don’t make this a brawl about them
lotrmuhfukka

im sorry, but a ring that makes you invisible is a lot more useful than a stick that goes boom. *put ring on* *walk to harry* **stabbbbbb* the end.

CantSpellMyName

The Ring doesn’t protect Frodo from harm, it only makes him invisible. Any destructive spell would have the same effect on Frodo as on anyone else. Protego against Sting and homenum revelio against the Ring and it should be piece of cake for Harry, all it goes down to is if Harry is smart enough to use his powers wisely. And either way, Frodo doesn’t have an advantage just because he has the ring, because Harry has an invisibility device as well and there is nothing that suggests that Frodo would put his ring on before Harry puts on his invisibility cloak. So I’d say that invisibility cloak + wand trumps invisibility ring + sword. Peace out.

darth death

Hobbits are resistant against magic!

CantSpellMyName

Avada kedavra would work just as fine against a hobbit as against a human, so even if Impedimenta would only stagger a hobbit instead of knocking him to the ground (which I doubt), the Killing curse would send any hobbit to the afterlife.

Watcher198

Yeah, when Frodo use The One Ring, he goes to another world that Harry doesn’t see, so even with the invisibility cloak Harry could not kill Frodo.

CantSpellMyName

Homenum revelio

Watcher198

That’s a great argument CantSpellMyName, but this spell just work with muggles and witches, and Frodo is a Hobbit.

Ggirl

Lol, i agreed with you…

observer

Frodo can see Harry through Cloak because Frodo when wearing One Ring enter into world of ghosts and shadows. I dont know if Harry could see Frodo with that spell, because that shadow world (Nazguls as undead belong to it) isnt simple invisibility, hobbit is more like undead in that realm.

CannotSpellMyName

There is no way we can know that because we can’t compare magic in LotR with magic from Harry Potter, they are completely different forces which have shown to do completely different things. Therefore, it is possible that homenum revelio would work against Frodo’s invisibility, and it is equally possible that it wouldn’t, just like it is possible that Frodo could see through Harry’s invisibility cloak, and equally possible that is couldn’t, simple as that.

Watcher198

My friend, Homenun Revelio only works with humans, and Frodo is a HOBBIT…

CantSpellMyName

Nothing suggests that Homenum Revelio wouldn’t work with hobbits, we haven’t seen homenum revelio used against semi-human creatures such as Centaurs, House Elfs, Giants etc. in the Harry Potter series so you cannot exclude the possibility that it might work against hobbits. Also, magic in Harry Potter can be used with far greater versatility than in LotR, inventing a spell (if there isn’t one already) that reveals the presence of other creatures than humans wouldn’t be rocket science. People seem to think that just because Frodo has the Ring he’s friggin’ unbeatable, and that just isn’t any more true than claiming that Spiderman is unbeatable because he has a spider sense.

Sabihj amal

frodo is a better character but in a fight harry will win
shiter

frodo can only pee on harry but harry can kill frodo
Thiaguinho_cric

I like more than Lord of the Rings, but I must admit that it is weaker, while frodo went through secret passages to pass unnoticed by orcs, Harry did not care to kill dementors,and more, harry is strong with these super cool spells, but Frodo should take some credit,since he has come a long way! muuito long! in order to destroy the ring, even with thedamn smiglle side. But Harry still wins by more dots in my opinion!
Some people will wish that my death nonetheless voted for Frodo ’-’
if I did not vote on it I’d feel like a traitor!

If I said something wrong, excuse me is that I never had the opportunity to read the books(more’ve seen the movies, actually). And if I spoke many words wrong botem blamegoogle translator! is that I do not speak the language of you.
Ana_dgc

Frodo have sam.
Maybe Frodo and Sam would loose, but send harry potter to mordor and the we’ll see who win.
One does not simply walk into mordor my friends
http://profile.yahoo.com/IYJ5EV3JRFJH5OVMJOLB2LY2U4 Sarah Torgerson

Maybe we should be tackling supreme evils.
Voldemort VS Sauron
…………or sauruman, since he is also a wizard.
Bellatrix Ellude

Lord of the rings: The book is all about addiction Frodo: Along with saving everybody by dyestroying the ring, he also resists the addiction of the ring in the end and almost gives up his life for thousands
Harry Potter: The book is all about a snobby teenager Harry: Saves wizards and gets the girl, almost gives his life up for hundreds

Frodo also travels thousands of miles in all three books with only a sword and he wants his friends to stay behind, but they say no.
Harry only travels in the last book and never by himself and he has almost unlimited power
Frodo acomplishes more with less
Hary acomplishes less with more.
Frodo, but only by an inch

Hobbit vs. Wizard

Related Posts

Voldemort vs. Saruman

Gandalf vs. Dumbledore

Blade vs. Edward Cullen

Yoda vs Voldemort

Kratos FTW says: Kratos will smash Thor in the head with his own Hammer. He...

Midike760 says: You moron. Sonic DOES carry powerups. He has the chaos emeralds, and...

BRAIN.EXE says: Sheldon probably knows self-defense from every sci-fi culture ever. Vulcan, Mandalorian, Romulan......

G_Hendricks says: Yes, but remember that Vulcans are much stronger than humans. So I’ll...

Find us on Facebook

Subscribe & Follow

Recent Brawls

Tom Haverford vs Jean Ralphio

Abed Nadir vs Troy Barnes

Iron Man vs Hulk

Captain America vs Thor

Recent Tweets

Suggest a Brawl