Who Would Win in a Brawl?!

Dude… Sam killed a giant spider. What has Ron done? Almost died from drinking poison? Yeah. That’s it.

I may be half in love with Mr. Weasley, but I still believe that Sam would trounce him… magic or no magic.

What, are you all retarded? Ron's fought more opponents, tougher opponents all before he realized tits were to be played with than Sam did ever. Sam fought Shelob once. Whoopity shit. Ron fought evil archmages before he could cast a decent spell and lived.

If there was a giant spider involved, Sam would win hands down while Ron cried in a corner…
If there was no spider, Ron would win purely because he can use magic.
If it was a muggle-fight, i.e no weapons Sam would win because hobbits are tough.
And if Frodo was involved, Sam would win because he's so loyal.
And if there was a great food feast for the winner… well, that would be a fight to remember.
(:

Ron is just another geek thought up by J.K. Rowling.
Sam is another great, grand, lovable, brave, and well thought up character from J.R.R. Tolkien the god.

Sam is brave, Ron is a coward, Sam wins

I love both characters, but I have to say that Sam would win. He’s got the heart and loyalty to overcome anything. In the whole of the series, Ron sort of accomplishes things by accident.

Now THIS is a good one! Both of them are heroic and loyal and both of them grow from being quite whiny into throwing themselves into mortal peril to fight for their friends and to save their worlds. I really feel that they are equally awesome, Ron would win in a fight though but it wouldn’t stop Sam from fighting with heart and soul.

Whoa, hold your horses! Ron is every bit as loyal and heroic as Sam is, and he didn’t accomplish things by accident, stabbing the Horcrux wasn’t an accident, saving Harry’s life several times wasn’t an accident, being the heart of the Trio and maintaining their bonds with his humor and heart wasn’t an accident, and winning the love of the most brilliant witch of her age wasn’t an accident. Sam is awesome but you have to acknowledge Ron and the things he’s done.

Ron isn’t a coward, where did you get that from? He risked his life in every book even though he didn’t have to, he’s as loyal and brave as Sam is. He’s one of few gingers who has a soul, that’s nothing to sneeze at either, lol.

Are you saying that J.K. Rowling doesn’t know how to invent good characters?

You should be ashamed of yourself for making such an erroneous statement.

Now i see here, a true fan of Harry Potter, man, all of the comments i see you, you protect the people of Harry Potter. Now let me make you some questions:
1st – Why do you hate John Ronald R. Tolkien?
2nd – Why do you think Ron, the coward (sorry for say that, but that’s my point) can wins a battle agains Sam.

After all, brave persons do everything to survive. Ron would run, if Ron, find the ring, he would fall by the magic.
And i am not saying i realy HATE Harry Potter (i watched all movies and i read some parts of the books), but Tolkien created a Universe, a Middle Earth… J.K Rowling just put her history in this fool world…

Dear Mr. CantSpellMyName, i hope you undestand my message, you must follow what is wise, to answer such a thing, Tolkien’s characters are amazing and they do everything to survive, you can vote, but you have to think first.

She have great characters.

Ron my friend only have powers because o the cursed wands created by J.K, he doesn’t kill anyone in the books, and Sam doesn’t have magic, he kill many foes using a sword and the Light of Earendil. 

Sam would win because of his courage and strength.

Hate JRR Tolkien??? Dude, are you serious?? Sir Tolkien is probably the greatest thing that has happened to litterature since Shakespeare! Without LOTR, there probably would be no Harry Potter. And while I prefer JK Rowling’s characters and her amazing ability to tell stories with lots of subplots that are woven together brilliantly and a unique continuity in her story-telling that stand out from the sadly typical “hero goes there, then he goes there and then he ends up there”, Tolkien is by all means the master of mythology (hell, he even invented entire languages), and I highly doubt that we will ever again see an author who can create an equally complex world. And I still need you to elaborate on why you think Ron is a coward. It is possible that Ron would indeed succumb to the temptations of the Ring’s power, but we don’t know that as he has never visited Middle-Earth (Frodo succumbed to the Ring’s power power too so you’d have to cut Ron some slack if he did). I do agree that Sam is braver than Ron, but Ron is brave enough, he risks his life for Harry many times during the books, not many friends would do what he has done. I’m not biased to Harry Potter, even though I do love the series, I just think that magic trumps skill with the sword.

Well yeah, if it was a contest of bravery and strength, Ron would probably be pretty fucked (unless Hermione was in danger, lol). Though in this contest I go by their natural weapons, and even if Sam is braver, a simple protection charm would prevent him from even get to Ron. All respect to Sam though, he’s a rolemodel for all sidekicks and a symbol for bravery and loyalty, I’d really prefer if they lay their weapons down and had a drink together while sharing stories, I bet Ron would love to get introduced to the liquors of the Shire, lol.

Oh yea!

But i stand with Sam, he is fat and is funny

But Sam has taken lives before has been in many fights. Ron hasn’t killed anyone and is kind of an idiot

Continuing Leonel’s commentary, a agreed with you CannotSpellMyName, but J.K’s characters only have enough strength because of the wands, Yeah, it will be wonderful with they drink liquors toghether’s, but i stand my word with Sam…

In which way is Ron an idiot? Are you sure you’re familiar with Ron Weasley from Harry Potter and not Lon Measly from Barry Trotter? Ron has probably been in more fights than Sam has, he has more than enough skill to defeat any sword-wielder in the world. Superman hasn’t taken any lives either, you think Sam could take him too?

Ya with a stick….. Let’s take that wand alway and see how long he last I love HP but Sam would totally own him…..

This fight isn’t wandless Ron vs. sword-wielding Sam, it says Ron vs. Sam and Ron’s natural weapon is a wand and he carries it with him always. So you can’t take the wand out of the equation.

Both of them are cool ones, i love Sam, he’s pretty cute, and in this battle Ron will have to take a weapon, such the Griffyndor sword, and fight honestly against Sam, because if Ron use his wand against Sam, he have only to say Avada Kedavra and Kill Sam, so please remove his wand and make a just battle.

YEEEEEAAAHHHHH SAM COULD KICK THAT LITTLE WEASLEYS BUTT IN A FIGHT ANY DAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! besides, magic isnt even real….but swords are.

Enough with this flamewar against Ron already. I understand that you guys love Sam, and I agree whole-heartedly that he’s a great character and a rolemodel to all loyal friends, and in a physical fight without magic he would probably beat Ron, but you have to cut Ron some slack, he’s done much more for Harry than most people would do to their friends. If Sam and Ron met for real, they would probably become best friends right away and have a drink together. Peace and love, everyone!

Since I know nothing about Sam since the only book I read from JRR Tolkien was The Hobbit and I was forced to read that, and I really dislike Ron, I don’t really care who would win that fight. Going along with the title, though, a wizard would beat a hobbit any day. A normal hobbit that is. IDK about Sam and Ron.

I have been saying magic beats sword the whole time.  gandalf over obi wan,  harry potter over frodo.  ect.  but this fight,  sam wins.   sam is the toughest person in the lord of the rings and the second toughest in all pop culture.  (link being the first) besides sam uses pots and pans,  wich not only beat swords,  but magic too

No matter who wins, one thing’s for sure: trying to get information from Sam by using the Cruciatus curse on him would be futile, he would stay loyal to the end.

i bet if we put any character from lord of the rings and place it against GOD, people would still go for lord of the rings.WTF?

Wait til you confront Superman fanboys…

trueeeee!!!

Sam is tough,brave and loyal he has shown far greater loyalty to frodo then ron has to harry. Sam is one of the most loyal,breavest.toughest characters of all time.He has withstood in the face of danger without breaking a sweat and his loyalty to frodo is far greater the anything ron has ever shown.Through out the book ron as been jealous of harry potter because he thinks he is living in the shadow of the chosen one.Sam has never shown any jealousy or hate towards  frodo he has shown nothing but  love and loyalty.Ron abandoned harry in the forest just because  he thought that harry didn’t had any plan to go through with there mission.Frodo thought sam to be a traitor and told him to go back and sam still came  back to save frodo’s life.Even with the strength and power disadvantage sam can still win this.