Is this a joke or something? You might as well have made it:
Harry Potter vs. A Damp Sponge
Harry Potter vs. Moldy Cheese in the Back of the Refrigerator
Harry Potter vs. A Slightly Deflated Balloon
says the twilight lover -_-
” vs moldywarts
This question is blasphemy. Even without a wand Harry would just have to point out that Edward’s hair was looking greasy and Edward would flee to the nearest beauty saloon to check his hair.
i’m with ya, see, i don’t hate Harry Potter
Have I ever implied that you do?
As much as I hate Edward, he’d easily snap Harry’s neck with his vampire speed+strength before he even thinks to lift his wand
Protego will do just fine against Edward’s attacks and Edward isn’t a light-speeder, Harry would definitely have time to raise his wand and erect the forcefield. Also, it may be so that Harry’s sacrificial protection given to him by his mother would prevent Edward from even touching him.
He may not be a light-speeder but he’s definitely inhumanly fast. For Harry to even stand a chance, he’d need to be prepared beforehand. I’m pretty sure Protego guards against magic only so he’d still be vulnerable to physical attacks. Harry’s sacrificial protection only stops Voldermort from touching him. It won’t activate when Edward starts slapping the life out of him…
Furthermore, Harry doesn’t know many (or any) area attacks that would help. All his spells are directional and need him to point at the target which Edward would definitely be fast enough to dodge
Dude, i hate both of this books, but one moment in my life, i stand with Harry, he can use Petrificus Totales in Edward when this one try to grab his neck, and after that, AVADA KEDAVRA.
Totally true, my friend But… You hate Harry Potter? Why, man?
Because everybody just say that Harry Potter is best than any other books, and is a enemy for LOTR, in all polls, the people vote for Voldemort, J.k’s characters are not the most powerful, the Harry Potter fans must see the other side, like Gandalf vs Dumbledore or Voldy vs Saruman, but when i see this poll i have to agree with you Potter fans, because it’s a wizard vs a vampire suck who shine in the sun. LOL.
But i respect you all, ad to prove that, i vote for Harry because this is a just battle and Harry is definitely more powerful than this greaseball.
Harry doesn’t use avada kedavra he only used it once and that was against voldemort but that was the only time he ever used it but he would still win he also could get a sword with accio sword DUH
No, Protego works against physical attacks as well – in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, the Protego charm that Hermione erects to prevent a Horcrux-manipulated Ron from attacking Harry also prevents her from running after Ron when he leaves them moments later; she had to remove the charm before she could run after him. So Protego will work just fine against Edward. The movie versions of Half-Blood Prince and Deathly Hallows also shows a different type of forcefield that disintegrates whatever or whoever tries to break through it, and while we do not know if there is such a charm in the books, it is plausible to think that there is as there are no precise limits to what magic can do other than those mentioned in the books (resurrecting dead people, etc.) Sorry but Edward would be fucked if he faced Harry, Harry has trained his reaction speed to a far higher extent than most humans thanks to his experienced years as a Quidditch seeker, he has also fought Death Eaters on broomsticks, which are far faster than Edward. As much as I dislike Edward (because I really do, in fact there isn’t a single thing about him I even remotely appreciate), as an unbiased observer of this fight I can conclude that Harry will curbstomp Edward’s ass into oblivion.
Protego defends against physical attacks – in 7th book Hermione casted Protego so Ron and Harry wouldn’t fight, and harry would definetely without thinking would cast that spell.
Harry would win.
Protego IS physical barrier. That’s why after Hermionie cast it to keep Ron and Harry from fighting in the last book she couldn’t get to Ron when he was leaving. Duh I bet even 1st years know more than you.
Dude… This discussion ended 2 years ago and your point was already made. Keep up
this is the world’s most ridiculous comparision
This isn’t meant to be a popularity contest. Edward is fast enough to run up behind you and rip your head off before your brain could process who you were looking at.
Lol, no. Harry isn’t a slouch, he’s an experienced quidditch player with awesome reaction time and he has countered countless spells, he would definitely have the time to erect a protection charm and then stupefy Edward’s shiny ass into oblivion.
Harry would use Oblivate and Edward would forget whatever he was doing.
we are comparing the boy who stood up against the most powerful dark wizard ever to save the entire wizard world against the vampire who fights a red head to save a girl
Best. Comment. Ever.
this is how the fight would go
hary: houcuse pocuse!!
hary ta dah! (pulls rabit out of hat)
edward: oh hes so cute
rabit: (beats the shit out of edward)
Pretty much, yeah x)
harry whoops the sparkling vampire
I love harryho pottera, hermiona is just super, and ron weasley is a miksop but nice
okay, if harry’s a quidditch master with fast reflexes, you’re counting out cullen’s mind-reading. he knows what harry’s going to do before potter boy actually casts the spell. just cause you hate twilight doesnt mean you have to be illogical. speed+telepathy > wand+quidditch skillls
Occlumency blocks mind-reading abilities.
Edward would use his speed to break harry’s wand and then just go to work…. without the heavy lifting.
Harry killed Voldemort. Voldemort killed Cedric Diggory. Cedric Diggory became a love stricken pale little boy when he realized he got written out of the Harry Potter books.
Well, this was almost hard for me to decide because I can’t decide which of these characters I hate more! I would say that as much as I hate him, Harry would definitely win. I mean, what can Edward do? Sparkle Harry to death?
Lets see we have a boy who killed the greatest dark wizard ever and cheated death once and we have a vampire that is trying to save a red head bitch….. *facepalm*
`Harry cheated death twice brah
Harry: AVADA KEDAVRA
If you think about this logically and without bias then you see that these two are actually pretty evenly matched. Harry Potter is one of the most powerful wizards, but Edward is about a thousand times stronger and faster. If we are assuming that Harry has at lease one second to prepare, he could protect himself by encircling himself with fire, which can destroy vampires (or just a shield charm). While Edward tries to get to Harry, Harry could immobilize Edward, thus winning the brawl.
If Harry Potter was not some kind of chosen one Voldemort could have fought dozens of him or more without problem. Harry is a mediocre wizard.
Harry Potter can defeat the world greatest, most evil sorcerer in the world when he was just a baby because of his mother’s love, live with being an orphan, suffer 10 FUCKING YEARS without love and still survive, learn he’s a wizard, go to Hogwarts, become the youngest Seeker in a century on his first time on a broomstick, face Voldemort and defeat his servant and him, escape from his unloving family on a flying car cos he’s just that badass, illegally have Polyjuice Potion, escape from giant hungry spiders, speak to snakes, get into the Chamber of Secrets, face Tom Riddle, who FYI, is Voldemort, kill an enormous snake who kills people if they look into their eyes, destroy Tom Riddle, save his best friend’s sister Ginny, blow up his aunt Marge, have a ride on the Knight bus, fight off a hundred Dementors at once, find out the truth about his Godfather Sirius Black, save Sirius, ride on a Hippogriff and a new Firebolt, enter the Triwizard Contest which is for people way older than him and he didn’t enter himself, some mystery person did it for him, fight a dragon and win, come second in the next task but would’ve come first if he didn’t save a little girl as well, see his friend die, see Voldemort come back to power, fight with Voldemort AGAIN and win, escape, find out it was Moody who put his name in the Triwizard Cup, find out Moody is just an imposter, fight off two Dementors in the holidays, go to a full criminal trial because of it and get cleared of all charges, deal with nobody believing him Voldemort’s back, and I could go on FOREVER but I’ll just end it with Harry sacrificing himself for the world, find out he’s not dead, pretend to be dead and then defeat Voldemort, the most evil and most powerful and most sadistic wizard ever born. Edward Cullen can watch young girls sleep and….sparkle.
I am a die hard Harry Potter fan, camp outside the bookshop kid and all of that. And I do agree that Edward Cullen is a prissy, sparkly, touchy-feely, “tortured”, fake stone vampire (because I prefer fleshy vampires), who is made slightly worse by a glorified british teen heartthrob with big hair and weird nipples (justsaying). Plus the Twilight tale borders on stupid, while Harry Potter saves the world from a hell raining wizard nazi of pure evil.
-although I guess it’s a bonus to Stephanie Meyer because the twilight books were my guilty pleasure.
Let’s face it, Harry is a brilliant Wizard and has taken on some things that Edward Cullen probably couldn’t handle, like maybe dragons or probs Voldemort himself.
But at the end of the day Eddie boy is a vampire. In a realistic situation where Harry and Edward were one on one with the aim to kill. Edward could easily use super speed to get to Harry and break his neck before he could even utter his spell. However we are talking about do-gooder Edward Cullen so maybe he would just break his arm or wand or something and spare his life.
Edward Cullen sadly wins.
But Harry Potter wins in life and Edward Cullen eats wolf poo
just thought id point out that vampires from twilight die pretty much instantly if they set on fire, and a first year harry potter can summon a flame thrower in one word, so edward is pretty much screwed (and bella will cry she never got to do it herself)
Harry, all day long, no question.
It’s Harry Potter,U don’t have to ask!!!
I like them both but I think HARRY WOULD SOO WIN I have read all the books ant heroine is just the bomb she the BEST EVER
I love harry potter… but he never kills and this Edward dude doesn’t mind ripping the heads off people, and harry really couldn’t kill a vampire with super speed and strength with his wand. harry has morals and codes that makes him loveable but eddy kills in swarms laving him a moody hated sociopath.
i hate twilight and i’m a huge potterhead but if you think about it edward would win??? harry’s pretty good but still not an absolutely fantastic dueler, but edward has all that stuff with the unpuncturable (? idk) skin and super strength. so i’d say he’d probably win but harry is still a FAR better character because of this; he has realistic flaws and he isn’t ridiculously perfect like edward.
This is funny because not a SINGLE person actually looked at the fight. This is just a bunch of fanboys. Now lets actually look at the match-up. Unfortunately we don’t have a clue how Harry’s spells would effect the “diamond skin” attribute of Edward. Secondly, Edward is WAY to fast to get hit my any spells xD And last of all, Edward can read minds! He will know what Harry wants to do the second he wants to do it. I hate Twilight as much as the next guy but this sight is meant for intellectually debates about battles, not fanboy time. Edward wins hands down. Sorry
Harry has oclumency not to mention he can cheat death with the resurrection stone
Please, Harry defeated the most powerful dark wizard of all times when he was 17 with only a DISARMING spell. Heck, Harry kept Voldemort from getting the sorcerer’s stone when he was 11. Also Edward (Robert Patterson) is Cedric Diggory and he gets killed by Voldemort’s servant and then Harry (who is injured) goes on to duel Voldemort AND bring back Cedric’s body. And besides, Edward isn’t a vampire! He lives in a forest, he doesn’t eat people, and he SPARKLES. He is obviously a fairy. So, therefore, Harry Potter is WAY better than a sparkly fairy.
All of Harry’s major accomplishments you mentioned were not his own. He had A LOT of help at every turn. Alone, he’s actually a pretty mediocre wizard. Almost below average actually.
I’ve read both Harry Potter and Twilight books and I liked them both. I don’t think you know enough about the Twilight vampires to properly understand Edward’s abilities… Either that or you’re just trolling.
If this matchup was against a more intelligent, fast and experienced wizard like Severus Snape or pretty much any half decent Auror, Edward would probably get pushed back then get the beatdown of a lifetime. But against Harry… Harry wouldn’t be fast enough to properly assess the situation and use the appropriate area attack and protection spells in the first move. He may know a lot of spells but in the 0.5 second he’d have to react, he would default to expelliarmus which is useless against someone who doesn’t fight with a wand. Edward would snap his neck in a heartbeat. Sorry to bust your bubble there.
This is SIMPLE. Edward is dumb.
Got a suggestion for a brawl? Let us know!
Your Name (required)
Your Email (for contact purposes only - completely private)