I don’t think the doctor would ever hurt a human. Sherlock wins.
The Doctor has hurt a great many humans over the years, but they were all bad. Given the incarnation of Sherlock depicted is a sociopath, this might not be a problem.
iamhumanboy shut the hell up
Meh. Sherlock doesn’t have a TARDIS. or a sonic screwdriver. Not to mention Sherlock only has the ability to think of humanly things, whereas the Doctor has over 700 years of universal knowledge to firmly trump anything Sherlock could come up with.
Excuse me? I think at least 900 years of experience.
given the right circumstances the doctor on all accounts but iamhumanboy makes a pretty good point
He’s called ‘The Doctor’ not ‘Doctor Who’. That’s the name of the show.
Here, here. This should be changed.
Finally someone who gets that his name isn’t doctor who
The Doctor, no contest.
Depends. if we are assuming that the doctor will be willing to hurt sherlock, doctor wins.
It is Doctor just Doctor.
The doctor would travel back in time to when sherlock was a baby and rape him with the sonic screwdriver. Job done.
IT’S THE DOCTOR, NOT DOCTOR WHO! Pet peeve número uno right there.
THE DOCTOR doesn’t fight, so obviously Sherlock would win because he’s not at all opposed to it.
THE DOCTOR CAN LIKE TRAVEL IN TIME WITH HIS TARDIS!!!!! SHERLOCK HOLMES WOULDN”T EVEN HAVE A CHANCE TO BEAT HIM. THE DOCTOR CAN TRAVEL BACK IN TIME WHEN SHERLOCK IS A BABY AND HIT HIM WIDD HIS SONIC SCREWDRIVER
CHUCK NORRIS WOULD WIN!!!!!
A fight between them could very well end up a tie because while the Doctor has the sonic and the TARDIS it is shown in many episodes that sherlock is a good shot and can do really well in close combat and is much less forgiving than the Doctor.
WHOS RO DAH!
it would be easy for sherlock to win. he just puts a bullet in the doctors head, then fires again when he starts to glow
Dr Who will!!!
The Doctor will punch Sherlock!
SHERLOCK IS GAY!!!!!
Dr Who kills Sherlock.
Look at this picture down here!
Sherlock kills and tortures and likes guns.
doctor wont harm humans, hates guns, and loves smart people.
Sherlock would blow his brains out while doctor complements his logic and calls him beautiful
i love the doctor so doctor
Sherlock is a brilliant man with knowledge that is exclusively terrestrial. He knows more combat and it’s less forgiving than The Doctor, but I mean come on, The Doctor has memories of a thousand years, counting different languages, eras, and galaxies. Sherlock asks people to be quiet and not to be disturbed while he’s thinking, whereas the Doctor can deduct things no matter how overwhelming the situation is. At the end of the day, I think they’d both have a nice cup of tea while Watson and whoever is with the Doctor just sit there in silent.
sherlock holmes would build a time machine
Let’s face it, there will be nobody better then rose and the 10th doctor
Got a suggestion for a brawl? Let us know!
Your Name (required)
Your Email (for contact purposes only - completely private)